Monday, January 30, 2012

Aquinas

Saturday was the feast of St. Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas has been a daily companion of mine for several years. I'm currently translating the Summa Contra, and read a translation of the the Summa Theologica before that. I'm always shocked by how little of St. Thomas is read in seminaries, for his method and philosophy seem to be exactly the salve needed for so many postmodern irritations. The educated churchman knows something about Aquinas' five proofs, and perhaps recalls that he wrote a good bit about angels. On the whole, though, he is condemned part and parcel with the scholastic movement as a severe and inhuman logic-chopper, in contrast to the more presentable St. Francis, who had the good sense to be something of an environmentalist, and is thus given admission to favor. (I paraphrase the form of Chesterton's biography, as will be obvious to anyone who has read it.)

Despite the caricatures, Aquinas was a patient and beneficent man, the son of aristocratic parents whom he scandalized by entering monastic orders. His professional life was as a rationalist, but he was the sort of man who wrote openly amor Dei melior est quam cognitio. He is credited with baptizing the works of Aristotle, and his metaphysics are, as far as I can tell, unanswerable even after Kant, Hume, and Wittgenstein. Aquinas is most beneficial, however, despite what one who had only heard of the five proofs would think, not as a missionary to heathens who need reasoning with but to Christians who need Christianizing. By bringing Aristotle into Christendom he makes it more Christian, especially in a world gone wild with unreason.

The greatest good a re-reading of Aquinas might work would be to re-unite the substance of the Trinity against even those Orthodox who would insist on dividing God the purifying and saving spirit from God the creator. A great deal of Evangelical fervor is so committed to the salvation God works that it might have forgotten what is the good which God would save. If one can get through the rather long first portions of his books--for Aquinas always insists on starting at the very beginning, and never hurries through any argument--one discovers that this God of pure act, being-as-goodness, etc., is in his transcendent way rather surprisingly involved in solid and dirty things like soil and bushes and human beings.

Aquinas is also as polite as he is patient in his argument. He takes for granted that to argue with a man means to argue with him on his own grounds, and every chapter of the Summa begins with a shocking sentence such as "It seems there is no God..." which would then be answered by the things men hold in common (facts, accepted propositions, they manner in which these facts relate rationally to one another), and last of all, yet somehow without disrespect, some sentence along the lines of, "Holy Scripture also confirms this." In short, he always allows that there are several paths to the truth, precisely because there is only one truth, a truth of which he is never afraid.

The trouble about St. Aquinas is that he is a brilliantly simple author who translates dreadfully. A second year Latin student could read him with ease in his own tongue, but it takes someone with extraordinary English and exceptional concentration to read him translated. This morning I read the sentence: Adhuc, Si ens in potentia, inquantum huiusmodi, natum est moveri, quia quod potest esse potest non esse; sequitur ulterius divinam voluntatem esse variabilem. That's a fairly straightforward sentence in Latin words; but in English words, the clearest it might be rendered would be To this, if being is in potency, in so far as of this sort, it is made to be moved, since what is able to be is able not to be; which would follow last the divine will to be variable.

(Don't worry, St. Thomas rebuts this idea this in the next paragraph)

We lift our glasses, rationally, to the Dumb Ox.


This is, by the way, a very good wine.


Monday, January 23, 2012

Wait a Minute, Mr. Postman

I own an iPhone now. A month ago I was playing an RPO concert when my old cellphone was stolen from my coat pocket backstage, along with several purses (not mine) and the much more valuable phones contained therein. To my knowledge, none of the "smarter" phones in the purses were returned, but my cellphone (which had to be dialed via rotary wheel) was found lying on Monroe Avenue by a kind stranger several days later. It had been a great inconvenience to me to be without a cellphone even for a few days; I found that I missed it mostly as a timepiece. As I reflected on my situation I came to realize that if not even a thief wanted my old phone, I should probably get a new one.

So I did. I upgraded to an iPhone last week, and I love it. It can make phone calls, send text messages, check email, check facebook, take high quality photos and video, watch videos from Youtube, take notes, tell the weather, get the news, get maps and directions, tune, keep time, reference Hebrew, Latin, and Greek, download books, keep my bank account, and tell me which vintage wine to buy. So naturally, I thought of Neil Postman.

1) What is the probem to which my iPhone is a solution?
The iPhone trafficks more information and faster. It is exceeding convenient to have this information (maps, a calendar, a tuner) in my pocket in one small device. But, I admit, it would be easy to access all of the information the iPhone offers in the same way my parents and their parents did. I could keep maps in my car, I could keep a datebook in my pocket, and I could use an electronic tuner or even a tuning fork. The genius of the iPhone is that it makes accessing maps, calendars, and tuners entertaining.

2) Whose problem is it actually?
The problem is mine, if the problem is that I need to be entertained. Apparently I am become a dullard, if the outside world and its wonderful problems are boring. There are any number of real problems in my life and at large that urgently need solving, but none of them are rooted in being uninteresting. The problem is apparently that I am uninteresting, or even worse, uninterested.

3) What other problems will be created by my using this device?
For one, I don't think it's healthy to step so quickly and easily between the news that the Boko Haram are bombing Nigeria and my Scrabble game. They are, on the iPhone, literally two finger-flicks away. The problem of information scarcity is that one might never know about the Boko Haram or what they are doing. The problem of information glut is that, juxtaposed next to Scrabble and a hundred other trivialities, everything might begin to mean nothing at all. Secondly, I have already given up four or five human relationships since I've owned the device. I no longer have to speak with the bookseller in S-Port (I can buy books online easily now), I don't have to ask the attendant at the wineshop what New York vintage he'd recommend (I have that expertise on my phone), I don't have to speak to the receptionist at the optometrist (I can schedule an appointment on their website), I don't even need to stop by the LCS office to drop off my attendance (I can email it in.) Some of these problems aren't new to the iPhone, but the ease and centrality of the devices exacerbates these already-present problems. Lastly, and most terrifying of all, I've brought into this world a person for whom I am responsible who is growing up in an age where the iPhone is a given. It falls on me to teach him kind and charitable human relationships, the sensible ordering of one's worldview, and the balance between productive work and leisure, all while interpreting with him a device that is brand new for me.

Pray for James.